H.R. 3717 — 108th Congress

Broadcast Decency Enforcement Act of 2004

Originated in the House · Introduced Jan 21, 2004 · Science, Technology, Communications

Sponsor

Fred Upton

More bills from this sponsor

108th Congress
MeasureTitle
H.R. 1320 · Science, Technology, CommunicationsCommercial Spectrum Enhancement Act

Latest action

Mar 26, 2004

Read the second time. Placed on Senate Legislative Calendar under General Orders. Calendar No. 464.

CRS summary

As of Mar 11, 2004

Passed House amended

Broadcast Decency Enforcement Act of 2004 - (Sec. 2) Amends the Communications Act of 1934 to provide that if the violator of the terms and conditions of any Federal Communications Commission (FCC) license, permit, or certificate is either a broadcast station licensee or permittee or an applicant for a broadcast license, permit, or certificate, and such violator is determined by the FCC to have broadcast obscene, indecent, or profane material, the amount of forfeiture penalty shall not exceed $500,000 for each violation.

(Sec. 3) Directs the FCC, in enforcing penalties for violators, to take into account specified factors with respect to the violator's: (1) degree of culpability, including whether the offending material was live or recorded and scripted or unscripted; and (2) ability to pay, including whether the violator is a company or individual and the company's size. Provides an enforcement exception, under certain circumstances, for a licensee or permittee not owned or controlled by the network organization providing the offending material to the licensee or permittee for broadcast.

(Sec. 4) Makes the prohibition on penalties against nonlicensees inapplicable in the case of a person who utters obscene, indecent, or profane material broadcast by a licensee or permittee if such person willfully or intentionally makes the utterance.

(Sec. 5) Provides deadlines for actions on complaints of violations of this Act.

(Sec. 6) Authorizes the FCC, in addition to such penalties, to require the offending licensee or permittee to broadcast public service announcements that serve the educational and informational needs of children and reaches an audience of up to five times the audience estimated to have been reached by the obscene, indecent, or profane material.

(Sec. 7) Directs the FCC, in any subsequent proceeding against a broadcast licensee or permittee who has already paid a fine for violating the provisions of this Act or when a court has ordered payment of a penalty and such order has become final, to: (1) consider whether the broadcast of such material demonstrates a lack of character or other qualifications required to operate a station; and (2) treat such violation as a serious violation with respect to the determination of license or permit renewal.

(Sec. 9) Requires that if the FCC has issued a notice of violation in each of three or more proceedings during the term of the broadcast license and in each proceeding the fine was paid or a court has ordered payment of a penalty and such order has become final, then the FCC shall commence a proceeding to consider revocation of that station's license or permit.

(Sec. 10) Requires annual FCC reports to Congress to include information with respect to violations of this Act and related proceedings.

(Sec. 11) Requires the General Accounting Office to study and report to specified congressional committees on the complaints made to the FCC concerning the broadcasting of obscene, indecent, and profane material.

(Sec. 12) Expresses the sense of Congress that the broadcast television station licensees should reinstitute a family viewing policy for broadcasters that is similar to the policy that existed in the United States from 1975 to 1983.

Congressional Research Service, via api.congress.gov (public domain)

Roll-call votes

1 on record

Mar 11, 2004 · On Passage

Full roll call

Passed (391–22)

246 of 433 recorded votes are not yet matched to a member profile.

Yea391: 84 R · 79 D · 1 I

MemberPartyState
PORTER, Jon C.NV
RAMSTAD, JamesMN
DICKS, Norman DeValoisWA
HYDE, Henry JohnIL
CASTLE, Michael NewboldDE
WELLER, Gerald C.IL
SHADEGG, John B.AZ
BARTLETT, Roscoe GardnerMD
CHANDLER, A. B.KY
OTTER, C. L.ID
McINNIS, ScottCO
MOLLOHAN, Alan BowlbyWV
ALLEN, Thomas H.ME
PETERSON, JohnPA
WATT, Melvin L.NC
PUTNAM, AdamFL
MCCRERY, James O., IIILA
BALLENGER, CassNC
LAHOOD, Ray H.IL
LaTOURETTE, Steven C.OH
HART, Melissa A.PA
GILLMOR, Paul EugeneOH
COX, Charles ChristopherCA
SHERWOOD, DonPA
RYUN, JimKS
EHLERS, Vernon JamesMI
HOEFFEL, Joseph M.PA
AKIN, W. ToddMO
GORDON, Barton JenningsTN
GUTKNECHT, Gilbert W.MN
SWEENEY, John E.NY
HOSTETTLER, John NathanIN
LINDER, John ElmerGA
RENZI, RickAZ
JACKSON, Jesse L., Jr.IL
MOORE, DennisKS
BURNS, MaxGA
ROTHMAN, StevenNJ
BUYER, Stephen EarleIN
KILPATRICK, Carolyn CheeksMI
WEXLER, RobertFL
REYES, SilvestreTX
OWENS, Major Robert OdellNY
HAYWORTH, John D., Jr.AZ
JOHNSON, Timothy V.IL
FRANK, BarneyMA
BROWN-WAITE, VirginiaFL
HOBSON, David LeeOH
KENNEDY, MarkMN
OBEY, David RossWI
BONILLA, HenryTX
SIMMONS, RobertCT
GREENWOOD, James CharlesPA
CHOCOLA, ChrisIN
WATSON, Diane EdithCA
LAMPSON, Nicholas V.TX
LUCAS, KenKY
TAUSCHER, Ellen O'KaneCA
TANCREDO, Thomas G.CO
BASS, Charles FosterNH
SOUDER, Mark EdwardIN
TANNER, John S.TN
SHAYS, Christopher H.CT
DAVIS, Thomas M., IIIVA
KELLER, RichardFL
EVANS, Lane AllenIL
OSBORNE, ThomasNE
GREEN, MarkWI
NORTHUP, Anne MeagherKY
DEUTSCH, Peter R.FL
MANZULLO, Donald A.IL
REYNOLDS, Thomas M.NY
BROWN, Henry Edward, Jr.SC
BIGGERT, Judy BorgIL
HOOLEY, DarleneOR
RADANOVICH, George P.CA
McCOTTER, Thaddeus GeorgeMI
MUSGRAVE, Marilyn NCO
MILLER, BradNC
FERGUSON, MichaelNJ
TAYLOR, Gary EugeneMS
KOLBE, James ThomasAZ
SULLIVAN, JohnOK
ORTIZ, Solomon P.TX
WILSON, HeatherNM
SOLIS, Hilda L.CA
TURNER, JimTX
BOUCHER, Frederick C.VA
KNOLLENBERG, JosephMI
CRANE, Philip MillerIL
OBERSTAR, James LouisMN
BOYD, F. Allen, Jr.FL
LANTOS, Thomas PeterCA
MILLENDER-MCDONALD, JuanitaCA
HOUGHTON, Amory, Jr.NY
TOWNS, EdolphusNY
McCARTHY, KarenMO
STRICKLAND, TedOH
MURTHA, John Patrick, Jr.PA
POMBO, Richard WilliamCA
DELAHUNT, BillMA
McHUGH, John MichaelNY
DREIER, David TimothyCA
HINCHEY, Maurice DunleaNY
FORD, Harold, Jr.TN
WOOLSEY, Lynn C.CA
GILCHREST, Wayne ThomasMD
MARSHALL, JimGA
YOUNG, Charles WilliamFL
TAYLOR, Charles HartNC
DAVIS, ArturAL
CANTOR, EricVA
MEEHAN, Martin ThomasMA
REHBERG, DennyMT
BARRETT, James GreshamSC
DOOLEY, Calvin M.CA
DeLAY, Thomas DaleTX
JOHNSON, Nancy LeeCT
BACA, JoeCA
BOSWELL, Leonard L.IA
STENHOLM, Charles WalterTX
INSLEE, Jay RobertWA
PLATTS, ToddPA
STEARNS, Clifford BundyFL
WELDON, Wayne CurtisPA
SKELTON, Isaac Newton, IVMO
WU, DavidOR
HEFLEY, Joel M.CO
CANNON, Christopher B.UT
ABERCROMBIE, NeilHI
CUBIN, Barbara L.WY
KELLY, Sue W.NY
FROST, Jonas MartinTX
DAVIS, JimFL
SCHROCK, EdwardVA
HULSHOF, KennyMO
REGULA, Ralph StrausOH
SANDLIN, Max A.TX
BRADLEY, JebNH
PICKERING, Charles W. (Chip), Jr.MS
DAVIS, LincolnTN
DeMINT, James W.SC
GOODE, Virgil H., Jr.VA
KILDEE, Dale EdwardMI
COSTELLO, Jerry FrancisIL
SABO, Martin OlavMN
SPRATT, John McKee, Jr.SC
BOEHLERT, Sherwood LouisNY
EVERETT, Robert TerryAL
LEWIS, RonKY
KLECZKA, Gerald DanielWI
CRAMER, Robert E. (Bud), Jr.AL
HOLDEN, Thomas TimothyPA
BEREUTER, Douglas KentNE
ROSS, Michael AveryAR
WAMP, Zachary PaulTN
COLLINS, Michael AllenGA
MEEK, Kendrick B.FL
CUNNINGHAM, RandallCA
POMEROY, Earl Ralph, IIIND
BALLANCE, Frank W., Jr.NC
DUNN, Jennifer BlackburnWA
HOEKSTRA, PeterMI
ETHERIDGE, Bobby R.NC
STUPAK, Bart T.MI
BILIRAKIS, MichaelFL
FEENEY, TomFL
KENNEDY, Patrick JosephRI
EMERSON, Jo AnnMO
MAJETTE, Denise L.GA
KANJORSKI, Paul E.PA
SNYDER, Victor F.AR
MYRICK, SueNC
JEFFERSON, William JenningsLA
CARSON, BradOK
BEAUPREZ, BobCO
QUINN, John FrancisNY
SMITH, Nick H.MI
THOMAS, William MarshallCA
MATSUI, Robert T.CA
SHAW, Eugene Clay, Jr.FL
DEAL, John NathanGA
NEY, Robert WilliamOH
JENKINS, William LewisTN
BURTON, Danny LeeIN
WEINER, Anthony D.NY
LEACH, James Albert SmithIA
HARRIS, KatherineFL
ENGLISH, Philip SheridanPA
NORWOOD, Charles W., Jr.GA
FILNER, BobCA
EDWARDS, Thomas ChesterTX
LIPINSKI, William OliverIL
BERRY, Robert MarionAR
ANDREWS, Robert ErnestNJ
GOSS, Porter J.FL
GEPHARDT, Richard AndrewMO
DIAZ-BALART, LincolnFL
DAVIS, Jo AnnVA
WALSH, James T.NY
EMANUEL, RahmIL
BONO, MaryCA
FOLEY, Mark A.FL
ALEXANDER, RodneyLA
WELDON, David JosephFL
HERGER, Walter WilliamCA
OXLEY, Michael GarverOH
McNULTY, Michael RobertNY
GALLEGLY, Elton W.CA
NUSSLE, James AllenIA
HILL, Baron P.IN
PAYNE, Donald MilfordNJ
WYNN, Albert RussellMD
HUNTER, Duncan LeeCA
NETHERCUTT, George R., Jr.WA
BAKER, Richard HughLA
PENCE, MikeIN
ISTOOK, Ernest James, Jr.OK
OLVER, John WalterMA
GONZALEZ, Charles A.TX
PRYCE, Deborah D.OH
BONNER, Jr., Josiah RobinsAL
CARSON, Julia MayIN
HAYES, Robert CannonNC
SAXTON, Hugh JamesNJ
OSE, DougCA
TIAHRT, ToddKS
Ed PastorDemocratAZ
Adam B. SchiffDemocratCA
Anna G. EshooDemocratCA
George MillerDemocratCA
Grace F. NapolitanoDemocratCA
Linda T. SánchezDemocratCA
Lois CappsDemocratCA
Lucille Roybal-AllardDemocratCA
Mike ThompsonDemocratCA
Nancy PelosiDemocratCA
Sam FarrDemocratCA
Susan A. DavisDemocratCA
Xavier BecerraDemocratCA
Diana DeGetteDemocratCO
John B. LarsonDemocratCT
Rosa L. DeLauroDemocratCT
Alcee L. HastingsDemocratFL
Corrine BrownDemocratFL
David ScottDemocratGA
Sanford D. Bishop, Jr.DemocratGA
Ed CaseDemocratHI
Bobby L. RushDemocratIL
Luis V. GutiérrezDemocratIL
Peter J. ViscloskyDemocratIN
Edward J. MarkeyDemocratMA
James P. McGovernDemocratMA
John F. TierneyDemocratMA
Michael E. CapuanoDemocratMA
Richard E. NealDemocratMA
Stephen F. LynchDemocratMA
Benjamin L. CardinDemocratMD
C. A. Dutch RuppersbergerDemocratMD
Chris Van HollenDemocratMD
Elijah E. CummingsDemocratMD
Steny H. HoyerDemocratMD
Michael H. MichaudDemocratME
John D. DingellDemocratMI
Sander M. LevinDemocratMI
Betty McCollumDemocratMN
Collin C. PetersonDemocratMN
Bennie G. ThompsonDemocratMS
David E. PriceDemocratNC
Mike McIntyreDemocratNC
Bill Pascrell, Jr.DemocratNJ
Frank Pallone, Jr.DemocratNJ
Robert MenendezDemocratNJ
Rush HoltDemocratNJ
Tom UdallDemocratNM
Carolyn McCarthyDemocratNY
Charles B. RangelDemocratNY
Eliot L. EngelDemocratNY
Gregory W. MeeksDemocratNY
Joseph CrowleyDemocratNY
Louise McIntosh SlaughterDemocratNY
Nita M. LoweyDemocratNY
Steve IsraelDemocratNY
Timothy H. BishopDemocratNY
Marcy KapturDemocratOH
Sherrod BrownDemocratOH
Tim RyanDemocratOH
Earl BlumenauerDemocratOR
Chaka FattahDemocratPA
Michael F. DoyleDemocratPA
Robert A. BradyDemocratPA
James R. LangevinDemocratRI
James E. ClyburnDemocratSC
Jim CooperDemocratTN
Eddie Bernice JohnsonDemocratTX
Gene GreenDemocratTX
Lloyd DoggettDemocratTX
Rubén HinojosaDemocratTX
Jim MathesonDemocratUT
James P. MoranDemocratVA
Adam SmithDemocratWA
Jim McDermottDemocratWA
Rick LarsenDemocratWA
Ron KindDemocratWI
Tammy BaldwinDemocratWI
Nick J. Rahall IIDemocratWV
Bernard SandersIndependentVT
Don YoungRepublicanAK
Mike RogersRepublicanAL
Robert B. AderholtRepublicanAL
Spencer BachusRepublicanAL
John BoozmanRepublicanAR
Jeff FlakeRepublicanAZ
Trent FranksRepublicanAZ
Dana RohrabacherRepublicanCA
Darrell IssaRepublicanCA
Devin NunesRepublicanCA
Edward R. RoyceRepublicanCA
Gary G. MillerRepublicanCA
Howard P. "Buck" McKeonRepublicanCA
Ken CalvertRepublicanCA
Ander CrenshawRepublicanFL
Ileana Ros-LehtinenRepublicanFL
John L. MicaRepublicanFL
Mario Diaz-BalartRepublicanFL
Jack KingstonRepublicanGA
Johnny IsaksonRepublicanGA
Phil GingreyRepublicanGA
Steve KingRepublicanIA
Tom LathamRepublicanIA
Michael K. SimpsonRepublicanID
John ShimkusRepublicanIL
Mark KirkRepublicanIL
Jerry MoranRepublicanKS
Ed WhitfieldRepublicanKY
Harold RogersRepublicanKY
David VitterRepublicanLA
Candice S. MillerRepublicanMI
Dave CampRepublicanMI
Fred UptonRepublicanMI
Mike RogersRepublicanMI
John KlineRepublicanMN
Roy BluntRepublicanMO
Sam GravesRepublicanMO
Howard CobleRepublicanNC
Richard BurrRepublicanNC
Walter B. JonesRepublicanNC
Lee TerryRepublicanNE
Christopher H. SmithRepublicanNJ
Frank A. LoBiondoRepublicanNJ
Rodney P. FrelinghuysenRepublicanNJ
Scott GarrettRepublicanNJ
Stevan PearceRepublicanNM
John A. BoehnerRepublicanOH
Michael R. TurnerRepublicanOH
Patrick J. TiberiRepublicanOH
Rob PortmanRepublicanOH
Steve ChabotRepublicanOH
Frank D. LucasRepublicanOK
Tom ColeRepublicanOK
Greg WaldenRepublicanOR
Bill ShusterRepublicanPA
Jim GerlachRepublicanPA
Joseph R. PittsRepublicanPA
Patrick J. ToomeyRepublicanPA
Tim MurphyRepublicanPA
Joe WilsonRepublicanSC
John J. Duncan, Jr.RepublicanTN
Marsha BlackburnRepublicanTN
Jeb HensarlingRepublicanTX
Joe BartonRepublicanTX
John Abney CulbersonRepublicanTX
John R. CarterRepublicanTX
Kay GrangerRepublicanTX
Kevin BradyRepublicanTX
Lamar SmithRepublicanTX
Mac ThornberryRepublicanTX
Michael C. BurgessRepublicanTX
Pete SessionsRepublicanTX
Ralph M. HallRepublicanTX
Randy NeugebauerRepublicanTX
Sam JohnsonRepublicanTX
Rob BishopRepublicanUT
Bob GoodlatteRepublicanVA
Frank R. WolfRepublicanVA
J. Randy ForbesRepublicanVA
Doc HastingsRepublicanWA
F. James Sensenbrenner, Jr.RepublicanWI
Paul D. RyanRepublicanWI
Thomas E. PetriRepublicanWI
Shelley Moore CapitoRepublicanWV

Nay22: 14 D

MemberPartyState
BERMAN, Howard LawrenceCA
STARK, Fortney Hillman (Pete), Jr.CA
KUCINICH, DennisOH
HARMAN, Jane L.CA
PAUL, Ronald ErnestTX
ACKERMAN, Gary LeonardNY
JONES, Stephanie TubbsOH
BAIRD, BrianWA
Raúl M. GrijalvaDemocratAZ
Barbara LeeDemocratCA
Henry A. WaxmanDemocratCA
Maxine WatersDemocratCA
Michael M. HondaDemocratCA
Zoe LofgrenDemocratCA
John LewisDemocratGA
Janice D. SchakowskyDemocratIL
Wm. Lacy ClayDemocratMO
Jerrold NadlerDemocratNY
José E. SerranoDemocratNY
Nydia M. VelázquezDemocratNY
Sheila Jackson LeeDemocratTX
Robert C. "Bobby" ScottDemocratVA

Not Voting20: 6 D · 3 R

MemberPartyState
CARDOZA, Dennis A.CA
LEWIS, Charles JeremyCA
FOSSELLA, Vito JohnNY
DOOLITTLE, John TaylorCA
BELL, ChrisTX
TAUZIN, Wilbert JosephLA
RODRIGUEZ, Ciro D.TX
BERKLEY, ShelleyNV
JOHN, ChristopherLA
GIBBONS, James A.NV
HASTERT, John DennisIL
Loretta SanchezDemocratCA
Mark UdallDemocratCO
Danny K. DavisDemocratIL
John Conyers, Jr.DemocratMI
Carolyn B. MaloneyDemocratNY
Peter A. DeFazioDemocratOR
Jeff MillerRepublicanFL
Roger F. WickerRepublicanMS
Peter T. KingRepublicanNY

Member pages currently show roll-call votes from the 119th Congress only. The “Member pages” column marks votes from that congress.