S. 2062 — 108th Congress

Class Action Fairness Act of 2004

Originated in the Senate · Introduced Feb 10, 2004 · Law

Latest action

Jul 8, 2004

Cloture not invoked in Senate by Yea-Nay Vote. 44 - 43. Record Vote Number: 154. (consideration: CR S7818-7819)

CRS summary

As of Feb 10, 2004

Introduced in Senate

Class Action Fairness Act of 2004 - Amends the Federal judicial code to specify the calculation of contingent and other attorney's fees in proposed class action settlements that provide for the award of coupons to class members.

Prohibits a Federal district court from approving: (1) a proposed coupon settlement absent a finding that the settlement is fair, reasonable, and adequate; (2) a proposed settlement involving payments to class counsel that would result in a net monetary loss to class members, absent a finding that the loss is substantially outweighed by nonmonetary benefits; or (3) a proposed settlement that provides greater sums to some class members solely because they are closer geographically to the court.

Specifies requirements for notices of proposed settlements.

Grants district courts original jurisdiction of any civil action in which the matter in controversy exceeds $5 million, exclusive of interest and costs, and is between citizens of different States, or citizens of a State and a foreign State or its citizens or subjects.

Lists those factors pursuant to which a district court may decline to exercise jurisdiction over a class action, and specifies those circumstances in which a district court must decline jurisdiction.

Sets forth provisions governing the removal of interstate class actions to Federal district court and the review on appeal of remand orders.

Directs the Judicial Conference of the United States to report on class action settlements, incorporating recommendations for best court practices to ensure fairness for class members and appropriate fees for counsel.

Congressional Research Service, via api.congress.gov (public domain)

Roll-call votes

1 on record

Jul 8, 2004 · On the Cloture Motion

Full roll call

Cloture Motion Rejected (44–43)

62 of 100 recorded votes are not yet matched to a member profile.

Yea44: 15 R

MemberPartyState
VOINOVICH, George VictorOH
LUGAR, Richard GreenIN
STEVENS, Theodore FultonAK
DOMENICI, Pete VichiNM
BUNNING, James Paul DavidKY
BROWNBACK, Sam DaleKS
MILLER, Zell BryanGA
DeWINE, MichaelOH
GREGG, Judd AlanNH
SPECTER, ArlenPA
THOMAS, Craig LyleWY
BOND, Christopher SamuelMO
SNOWE, Olympia JeanME
ALLARD, A. WayneCO
HUTCHISON, Kathryn Ann BaileyTX
COLEMAN, NormMN
NELSON, Earl BenjaminNE
SMITH, Gordon HaroldOR
DOLE, Elizabeth HanfordNC
BURNS, ConradMT
FRIST, William H.TN
LOTT, Chester TrentMS
TALENT, James MatthesMO
NICKLES, Donald LeeOK
BENNETT, Robert FosterUT
ALLEN, GeorgeVA
CHAFEE, Lincoln DavenportRI
WARNER, John WilliamVA
SUNUNU, John E.NH
Lisa MurkowskiRepublicanAK
Jeff SessionsRepublicanAL
Jon KylRepublicanAZ
Saxby ChamblissRepublicanGA
Chuck GrassleyRepublicanIA
Mike CrapoRepublicanID
Pat RobertsRepublicanKS
Mitch McConnellRepublicanKY
Susan M. CollinsRepublicanME
Thad CochranRepublicanMS
James M. InhofeRepublicanOK
Lindsey GrahamRepublicanSC
Lamar AlexanderRepublicanTN
John CornynRepublicanTX
Orrin G. HatchRepublicanUT

Nay43: 18 D · 2 R

MemberPartyState
INOUYE, Daniel KenHI
LAUTENBERG, Frank RaleighNJ
CORZINE, Jon StevensNJ
BINGAMAN, Jesse Francis (Jeff), Jr.NM
HOLLINGS, Ernest FrederickSC
FEINGOLD, Russell DanaWI
LIEBERMAN, Joseph I.CT
SARBANES, Paul SpyrosMD
DODD, Christopher JohnCT
JEFFORDS, James MerrillVT
BREAUX, John BerlingerLA
BAUCUS, Max SiebenMT
DORGAN, Byron LeslieND
CRAIG, Larry EdwinID
BAYH, EvanIN
KENNEDY, Edward MooreMA
KOHL, Herbert H.WI
LINCOLN, Blanche LambertAR
DASCHLE, Thomas AndrewSD
GRAHAM, Daniel RobertFL
AKAKA, Daniel KahikinaHI
DAYTON, MarkMN
CONRAD, KentND
Mark L. PryorDemocratAR
Dianne FeinsteinDemocratCA
Thomas R. CarperDemocratDE
Bill NelsonDemocratFL
Tom HarkinDemocratIA
Richard J. DurbinDemocratIL
Mary L. LandrieuDemocratLA
Carl LevinDemocratMI
Debbie StabenowDemocratMI
Harry ReidDemocratNV
Charles E. SchumerDemocratNY
Ron WydenDemocratOR
Jack ReedDemocratRI
Tim JohnsonDemocratSD
Patrick J. LeahyDemocratVT
Maria CantwellDemocratWA
Patty MurrayDemocratWA
John D. Rockefeller, IVDemocratWV
Richard C. ShelbyRepublicanAL
John McCainRepublicanAZ

Not Voting13: 2 D · 1 R

MemberPartyState
SANTORUM, Richard JohnPA
BYRD, Robert CarlyleWV
ENSIGN, John EricNV
HAGEL, Charles TimothyNE
CAMPBELL, Ben NighthorseCO
FITZGERALD, Peter G.IL
CLINTON, Hillary RodhamNY
KERRY, John ForbesMA
EDWARDS, JohnNC
BIDEN, Joseph Robinette (Joe), Jr.DE
Barbara BoxerDemocratCA
Barbara A. MikulskiDemocratMD
Michael B. EnziRepublicanWY

Member pages currently show roll-call votes from the 119th Congress only. The “Member pages” column marks votes from that congress.