H.R. 3538 — 111th Congress

Idaho Wilderness Water Facilities Act

Originated in the House · Introduced Sep 8, 2009 · Public Lands and Natural Resources

Latest action

Jan 20, 2010

On motion to suspend the rules and pass the bill, as amended Failed by the Yeas and Nays: (2/3 required): 225 - 191 (Roll no. 11).

CRS summary

As of Jan 19, 2010

Reported to House with amendment(s)

Idaho Wilderness Water Facilities Act - Directs the Secretary of Agriculture to issue a special use authorization to each of the 20 owners of a water storage, transport, or diversion facility located on National Forest System land in the Frank Church of No Return Wilderness and the Selway-Bitterroot Wilderness in Idaho for continued operation, maintenance, and reconstruction of such facility if it is determined that: (1) the facility was in existence on the date on which the land upon which it is located was designated as part of the National Wilderness Preservation System; (2) the facility has been in continuous use to deliver water for beneficial use on the owner's non-federal land since the date of designation; (3) the owner holds a valid water right for use of the water on such land under Idaho state law, with a priority date that predates such date; and (4) it is not practicable or feasible to relocate the facility to land outside of the wilderness and continue the beneficial use of water on the non-federal land.

Requires the Secretary, in a special use authorization under this Act, to: (1) allow the use of motorized equipment and mechanized transport for operation, maintenance, or reconstruction of a facility, if it is determined that the use is necessary to continue delivery of water to the non-federal land for beneficial uses and, after conducting a minimum tool analysis for a facility, that the use of nonmotorized equipment and nonmechanized transport is impracticable or infeasible; and (2) preclude use of the facility for the storage, diversion, or transport of water in excess of the water right.

Allows the Secretary, in such an authorization, to: (1) require or allow modification or relocation of a facility in the wilderness, as determined necessary, to reduce impacts to wilderness values if the beneficial use of water on the non-federal land is not diminished; and (2) require that the owner provide a reciprocal right of access across the non-federal property, in which case the owner shall receive market value for any right-of-way or other interest in real property conveyed to the United States. Permits the market value to be paid by the Secretary, in whole or in part, by the grant of a reciprocal right-of-way or by reduction of fees or other costs that may accrue to the owner in obtaining an authorization for water facilities.

Congressional Research Service, via api.congress.gov (public domain)

Roll-call votes

1 on record

Jan 20, 2010 · On Motion to Suspend the Rules and Pass, as Amended

Full roll call

Failed (225–191)

160 of 433 recorded votes are not yet matched to a member profile.

Yea225: 120 R · 22 D

MemberPartyState
DICKS, Norman DeValoisWA
CASTLE, Michael NewboldDE
SHADEGG, John B.AZ
BARTLETT, Roscoe GardnerMD
PUTNAM, AdamFL
LaTOURETTE, Steven C.OH
SESTAK, JoePA
FALLIN, MaryOK
BRIGHT, Bobby Neal, Sr.AL
ALEXANDER, RodneyLA
EHLERS, Vernon JamesMI
CAO, AnhLA
MOORE, DennisKS
BUYER, Stephen EarleIN
SHULER, HeathNC
BILBRAY, Brian P.CA
RICHARDSON, LauraCA
JOHNSON, Timothy V.IL
GRIFFITH, ParkerAL
BROWN-WAITE, VirginiaFL
WILSON, CharlieOH
ELLSWORTH, BradIN
SOUDER, Mark EdwardIN
TANNER, John S.TN
MANZULLO, Donald A.IL
BROWN, Henry Edward, Jr.SC
INGLIS, Robert DurdenSC
KUCINICH, DennisOH
BIGGERT, Judy BorgIL
McCOTTER, Thaddeus GeorgeMI
MILLER, BradNC
TAYLOR, Gary EugeneMS
LEE, Christopher JohnNY
SULLIVAN, JohnOK
BOUCHER, Frederick C.VA
DRIEHAUS, SteveOH
BOYD, F. Allen, Jr.FL
BOCCIERI, John A.OH
CHILDERS, Travis W.MS
KOSMAS, Suzanne M.FL
SALAZAR, JohnCO
KISSELL, LarryNC
MURTHA, John Patrick, Jr.PA
SCHMIDT, JeanOH
DREIER, David TimothyCA
HINCHEY, Maurice DunleaNY
BERKLEY, ShelleyNV
NYE, Glenn C., IIIVA
MASSA, Eric J.J.NY
MARSHALL, JimGA
YOUNG, Charles WilliamFL
CANTOR, EricVA
REHBERG, DennyMT
SPACE, ZackOH
TEAGUE, HarryNM
PLATTS, ToddPA
STEARNS, Clifford BundyFL
MACK, Connie, IVFL
MINNICK, WaltID
WAMP, Zachary PaulTN
POMEROY, Earl Ralph, IIIND
ALTMIRE, JasonPA
EMERSON, Jo AnnMO
MYRICK, SueNC
MURPHY, ScottNY
LUNGREN, Daniel EdwardCA
DEAL, John NathanGA
MITCHELL, Harry E.AZ
BURTON, Danny LeeIN
ARCURI, MichaelNY
HODES, PaulNH
KRATOVIL, Frank M., Jr.MD
DIAZ-BALART, LincolnFL
GIFFORDS, GabrielleAZ
BONO, MaryCA
DAVIS, Geoffrey C.KY
HERGER, Walter WilliamCA
GALLEGLY, Elton W.CA
PENCE, MikeIN
GONZALEZ, Charles A.TX
AUSTRIA, SteveOH
TIAHRT, ToddKS
CARNEY, ChrisPA
Ann KirkpatrickDemocratAZ
George MillerDemocratCA
Jackie SpeierDemocratCA
Susan A. DavisDemocratCA
Christopher MurphyDemocratCT
James A. HimesDemocratCT
David LoebsackDemocratIA
Daniel LipinskiDemocratIL
Joe DonnellyDemocratIN
Peter J. ViscloskyDemocratIN
Michael H. MichaudDemocratME
Mike McIntyreDemocratNC
Bill Pascrell, Jr.DemocratNJ
Dina TitusDemocratNV
Gregory W. MeeksDemocratNY
Jerrold NadlerDemocratNY
Nita M. LoweyDemocratNY
Kurt SchraderDemocratOR
Steve CohenDemocratTN
Henry CuellarDemocratTX
James P. MoranDemocratVA
Rick LarsenDemocratWA
Mike RogersRepublicanAL
Robert B. AderholtRepublicanAL
Spencer BachusRepublicanAL
John BoozmanRepublicanAR
Jeff FlakeRepublicanAZ
Trent FranksRepublicanAZ
Dana RohrabacherRepublicanCA
Darrell IssaRepublicanCA
Devin NunesRepublicanCA
Duncan HunterRepublicanCA
Edward R. RoyceRepublicanCA
Gary G. MillerRepublicanCA
Howard P. "Buck" McKeonRepublicanCA
John CampbellRepublicanCA
Ken CalvertRepublicanCA
Kevin McCarthyRepublicanCA
Tom McClintockRepublicanCA
Doug LambornRepublicanCO
Mike CoffmanRepublicanCO
Bill PoseyRepublicanFL
Gus M. BilirakisRepublicanFL
Ileana Ros-LehtinenRepublicanFL
Jeff MillerRepublicanFL
John L. MicaRepublicanFL
Mario Diaz-BalartRepublicanFL
Thomas J. RooneyRepublicanFL
Vern BuchananRepublicanFL
Jack KingstonRepublicanGA
Paul C. BrounRepublicanGA
Phil GingreyRepublicanGA
Tom PriceRepublicanGA
Steve KingRepublicanIA
Tom LathamRepublicanIA
Michael K. SimpsonRepublicanID
Aaron SchockRepublicanIL
John ShimkusRepublicanIL
Mark KirkRepublicanIL
Peter J. RoskamRepublicanIL
Jerry MoranRepublicanKS
Lynn JenkinsRepublicanKS
Brett GuthrieRepublicanKY
Ed WhitfieldRepublicanKY
Harold RogersRepublicanKY
Bill CassidyRepublicanLA
Charles W. Boustany Jr.RepublicanLA
John FlemingRepublicanLA
Steve ScaliseRepublicanLA
Candice S. MillerRepublicanMI
Dave CampRepublicanMI
Fred UptonRepublicanMI
Mike RogersRepublicanMI
Erik PaulsenRepublicanMN
John KlineRepublicanMN
Michele BachmannRepublicanMN
Blaine LuetkemeyerRepublicanMO
Roy BluntRepublicanMO
Sam GravesRepublicanMO
Gregg HarperRepublicanMS
Howard CobleRepublicanNC
Patrick T. McHenryRepublicanNC
Virginia FoxxRepublicanNC
Walter B. JonesRepublicanNC
Adrian SmithRepublicanNE
Jeff FortenberryRepublicanNE
Lee TerryRepublicanNE
Christopher H. SmithRepublicanNJ
Frank A. LoBiondoRepublicanNJ
Leonard LanceRepublicanNJ
Rodney P. FrelinghuysenRepublicanNJ
Scott GarrettRepublicanNJ
Dean HellerRepublicanNV
Peter T. KingRepublicanNY
Jim JordanRepublicanOH
John A. BoehnerRepublicanOH
Michael R. TurnerRepublicanOH
Patrick J. TiberiRepublicanOH
Robert E. LattaRepublicanOH
Frank D. LucasRepublicanOK
Tom ColeRepublicanOK
Greg WaldenRepublicanOR
Bill ShusterRepublicanPA
Charles W. DentRepublicanPA
Glenn ThompsonRepublicanPA
Jim GerlachRepublicanPA
Joseph R. PittsRepublicanPA
Tim MurphyRepublicanPA
David P. RoeRepublicanTN
John J. Duncan, Jr.RepublicanTN
Marsha BlackburnRepublicanTN
Jeb HensarlingRepublicanTX
Joe BartonRepublicanTX
John R. CarterRepublicanTX
K. Michael ConawayRepublicanTX
Kay GrangerRepublicanTX
Kenny MarchantRepublicanTX
Lamar SmithRepublicanTX
Louie GohmertRepublicanTX
Mac ThornberryRepublicanTX
Michael C. BurgessRepublicanTX
Michael T. McCaulRepublicanTX
Pete OlsonRepublicanTX
Pete SessionsRepublicanTX
Ralph M. HallRepublicanTX
Randy NeugebauerRepublicanTX
Sam JohnsonRepublicanTX
Ted PoeRepublicanTX
Jason ChaffetzRepublicanUT
Rob BishopRepublicanUT
Bob GoodlatteRepublicanVA
Frank R. WolfRepublicanVA
J. Randy ForbesRepublicanVA
Robert J. WittmanRepublicanVA
Cathy McMorris RodgersRepublicanWA
David G. ReichertRepublicanWA
Doc HastingsRepublicanWA
F. James Sensenbrenner, Jr.RepublicanWI
Paul D. RyanRepublicanWI
Thomas E. PetriRepublicanWI
Shelley Moore CapitoRepublicanWV
Cynthia M. LummisRepublicanWY

Nay191: 122 D · 2 R

MemberPartyState
BOREN, Daniel DavidOK
CHANDLER, A. B.KY
CARDOZA, Dennis A.CA
MOLLOHAN, Alan BowlbyWV
WATT, Melvin L.NC
MARKEY, BetsyCO
BERMAN, Howard LawrenceCA
GORDON, Barton JenningsTN
LINDER, John ElmerGA
KLEIN, RonFL
JACKSON, Jesse L., Jr.IL
ROTHMAN, StevenNJ
KILPATRICK, Carolyn CheeksMI
HARE, PhilIL
REYES, SilvestreTX
FRANK, BarneyMA
OBEY, David RossWI
HALL, JohnNY
WATSON, Diane EdithCA
KAGEN, StevenWI
DAHLKEMPER, Kathleen A.PA
PERRIELLO, TomVA
ORTIZ, Solomon P.TX
KILROY, Mary JoOH
RODRIGUEZ, Ciro D.TX
OBERSTAR, James LouisMN
BEAN, Melissa L.IL
TOWNS, EdolphusNY
DELAHUNT, BillMA
HARMAN, Jane L.CA
WOOLSEY, Lynn C.CA
HERSETH SANDLIN, StephanieSD
PAUL, Ronald ErnestTX
BACA, JoeCA
BOSWELL, Leonard L.IA
INSLEE, Jay RobertWA
SCHAUER, Mark H.MI
SKELTON, Isaac Newton, IVMO
WU, DavidOR
DAVIS, LincolnTN
McMAHON, Michael E.NY
KILDEE, Dale EdwardMI
COSTELLO, Jerry FrancisIL
ACKERMAN, Gary LeonardNY
SPRATT, John McKee, Jr.SC
SUTTON, BettyOH
HOLDEN, Thomas TimothyPA
ROSS, Michael AveryAR
CARNAHAN, RussMO
MEEK, Kendrick B.FL
ETHERIDGE, Bobby R.NC
STUPAK, Bart T.MI
KENNEDY, Patrick JosephRI
KANJORSKI, Paul E.PA
SNYDER, Victor F.AR
ADLER, John H.NJ
WEINER, Anthony D.NY
FILNER, BobCA
EDWARDS, Thomas ChesterTX
BERRY, Robert MarionAR
ANDREWS, Robert ErnestNJ
HALVORSON, Deborah L.IL
MELANCON, Charles J.LA
HILL, Baron P.IN
PAYNE, Donald MilfordNJ
OLVER, John WalterMA
BAIRD, BrianWA
Ed PastorDemocratAZ
Raúl M. GrijalvaDemocratAZ
Adam B. SchiffDemocratCA
Anna G. EshooDemocratCA
Barbara LeeDemocratCA
Brad ShermanDemocratCA
Doris O. MatsuiDemocratCA
Grace F. NapolitanoDemocratCA
Henry A. WaxmanDemocratCA
Jerry McNerneyDemocratCA
Jim CostaDemocratCA
John GaramendiDemocratCA
Judy ChuDemocratCA
Linda T. SánchezDemocratCA
Lois CappsDemocratCA
Loretta SanchezDemocratCA
Lucille Roybal-AllardDemocratCA
Maxine WatersDemocratCA
Michael M. HondaDemocratCA
Mike ThompsonDemocratCA
Sam FarrDemocratCA
Xavier BecerraDemocratCA
Zoe LofgrenDemocratCA
Diana DeGetteDemocratCO
Ed PerlmutterDemocratCO
Jared PolisDemocratCO
Joe CourtneyDemocratCT
John B. LarsonDemocratCT
Rosa L. DeLauroDemocratCT
Alan GraysonDemocratFL
Alcee L. HastingsDemocratFL
Corrine BrownDemocratFL
Debbie Wasserman SchultzDemocratFL
Kathy CastorDemocratFL
David ScottDemocratGA
Henry C. "Hank" Johnson, Jr.DemocratGA
John BarrowDemocratGA
John LewisDemocratGA
Sanford D. Bishop, Jr.DemocratGA
Mazie K. HironoDemocratHI
Bruce L. BraleyDemocratIA
Bill FosterDemocratIL
Bobby L. RushDemocratIL
Danny K. DavisDemocratIL
Janice D. SchakowskyDemocratIL
Luis V. GutiérrezDemocratIL
Mike QuigleyDemocratIL
André CarsonDemocratIN
John A. YarmuthDemocratKY
Edward J. MarkeyDemocratMA
James P. McGovernDemocratMA
John F. TierneyDemocratMA
Michael E. CapuanoDemocratMA
Niki TsongasDemocratMA
Richard E. NealDemocratMA
Stephen F. LynchDemocratMA
C. A. Dutch RuppersbergerDemocratMD
Chris Van HollenDemocratMD
Donna F. EdwardsDemocratMD
Elijah E. CummingsDemocratMD
John P. SarbanesDemocratMD
Steny H. HoyerDemocratMD
Chellie PingreeDemocratME
Gary C. PetersDemocratMI
John Conyers, Jr.DemocratMI
John D. DingellDemocratMI
Sander M. LevinDemocratMI
Betty McCollumDemocratMN
Collin C. PetersonDemocratMN
Keith EllisonDemocratMN
Timothy J. WalzDemocratMN
Wm. Lacy ClayDemocratMO
Bennie G. ThompsonDemocratMS
David E. PriceDemocratNC
G. K. ButterfieldDemocratNC
Carol Shea-PorterDemocratNH
Albio SiresDemocratNJ
Frank Pallone, Jr.DemocratNJ
Rush HoltDemocratNJ
Ben Ray LujánDemocratNM
Martin HeinrichDemocratNM
Brian HigginsDemocratNY
Carolyn B. MaloneyDemocratNY
Carolyn McCarthyDemocratNY
Charles B. RangelDemocratNY
Daniel B. MaffeiDemocratNY
Eliot L. EngelDemocratNY
José E. SerranoDemocratNY
Joseph CrowleyDemocratNY
Louise McIntosh SlaughterDemocratNY
Nydia M. VelázquezDemocratNY
Paul TonkoDemocratNY
Steve IsraelDemocratNY
Timothy H. BishopDemocratNY
William L. OwensDemocratNY
Yvette D. ClarkeDemocratNY
Marcia L. FudgeDemocratOH
Marcy KapturDemocratOH
Tim RyanDemocratOH
Earl BlumenauerDemocratOR
Peter A. DeFazioDemocratOR
Allyson Y. SchwartzDemocratPA
Chaka FattahDemocratPA
Michael F. DoyleDemocratPA
Robert A. BradyDemocratPA
James R. LangevinDemocratRI
James E. ClyburnDemocratSC
Jim CooperDemocratTN
Al GreenDemocratTX
Gene GreenDemocratTX
Lloyd DoggettDemocratTX
Sheila Jackson LeeDemocratTX
Jim MathesonDemocratUT
Gerald E. ConnollyDemocratVA
Robert C. "Bobby" ScottDemocratVA
Peter WelchDemocratVT
Adam SmithDemocratWA
Jim McDermottDemocratWA
Gwen MooreDemocratWI
Ron KindDemocratWI
Tammy BaldwinDemocratWI
Nick J. Rahall IIDemocratWV
Joe WilsonRepublicanSC
Kevin BradyRepublicanTX

Not Voting17: 4 R · 3 D

MemberPartyState
LEWIS, Charles JeremyCA
STARK, Fortney Hillman (Pete), Jr.CA
AKIN, W. ToddMO
RADANOVICH, George P.CA
DAVIS, ArturAL
BARRETT, James GreshamSC
MURPHY, PatrickPA
ABERCROMBIE, NeilHI
HOEKSTRA, PeterMI
BONNER, Jr., Josiah RobinsAL
Emanuel CleaverDemocratMO
Eddie Bernice JohnsonDemocratTX
Rubén HinojosaDemocratTX
Don YoungRepublicanAK
Ander CrenshawRepublicanFL
Lynn A. WestmorelandRepublicanGA
John Abney CulbersonRepublicanTX

Member pages currently show roll-call votes from the 119th Congress only. The “Member pages” column marks votes from that congress.