S. 2329 — 108th Congress

Scott Campbell, Stephanie Roper, Wendy Preston, Louarna Gillis, and Nila Lynn Crime Victims' Rights Act

Originated in the Senate · Introduced Apr 21, 2004 · Crime and Law Enforcement

Sponsor

Jon Kyl

Latest action

Jun 28, 2004

Referred to the Subcommittee on Crime, Terrorism, and Homeland Security.

CRS summary

As of Apr 22, 2004

Passed Senate amended

Scott Campbell, Stephanie Roper, Wendy Preston, Louarna Gillis, and Nila Lynn Crime Victims' Rights Act - Amends the Federal criminal code to provide that a crime victim has the following rights: (1) to be reasonably protected from the accused; (2) to reasonable, accurate, and timely notice of, and to not be excluded from, any public proceeding involving the crime or of any release or escape of the accused; (3) to be reasonably heard at any public proceeding involving release, plea, or sentencing; (4) to confer with the attorney for the Government in the case; (5) to full and timely restitution as provided in law; (6) to proceedings free from unreasonable delay; and (7) to be treated with fairness and with respect for his or her dignity and privacy. Directs the court to ensure that a victim is afforded these rights in any proceeding involving the offense and to clearly state on the record the reasons for any decision denying relief under this Act.

Requires officers and employees of the Department of Justice (DOJ) and other departments and agencies engaged in the detection, investigation, or prosecution of crime to make their best efforts to see that crime victims are notified of, and accorded, these rights. Requires the prosecutor to advise a crime victim of any material conflict of interest between the prosecutor and the victim, and to take reasonable steps to direct the victim to the appropriate legal referral, legal assistance, or legal aid agency. Provides that notice of release otherwise required under this Act shall not be given if it may endanger the safety of any person.

Authorizes the crime victim, the victim's lawful representative, and the Government attorney to assert the rights established under this Act. Directs the court, in a case where it finds that the number of victims makes it impracticable to accord all of the victims the rights contained in this Act, to fashion a procedure to give effect to this Act.

Authorizes the Government or the crime victim to apply for a writ of mandamus to the appropriate appeals court if a Federal court denies any right of a crime victim under this Act or under the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. Directs the court of appeals to decide such application and order such relief as necessary to protect the victim's ability to exercise these rights. Allows the Government, in any appeal in a criminal case, to assert as error the district court's denial of a victim's right in a proceeding. Provides that in no case shall a failure to afford a right under this Act provide grounds for a new trial.

Directs the Attorney General to promulgate regulations to enforce victims' rights and to ensure compliance by responsible officials with obligations respecting crime victims.

Repeals victims' rights provisions of the Victims' Rights and Restitution Act of 1990.

(Sec. 3) Amends the Victims of Crime Act of 1984 to authorize the Director of DOJ's Office for Victims of Crime (Office) to make grants to: (1) develop, establish, and maintain programs for the enforcement of crime victims' rights; and (2) develop and implement state-of-the-art systems for notifying crime victims of important dates and developments relating to criminal proceedings in a timely and efficient manner, provided that the jurisdiction has substantially equivalent provisions.

Authorizes appropriations for: (1) U.S. Attorneys Offices for Victim/Witnesses Assistance Programs; (2) the Office for enhancement of the Victim Notification System and for staff to administer the appropriation for the support of the National Crime Victim Law Institute or other specified organizations; and (3) the Office for support of the Institute and the establishment and operation of the Institute's programs to provide counsel for victims in criminal cases for the enforcement of crime victims' rights in Federal jurisdictions, and in States and tribal governments that have substantially equivalent provisions, or for other substantially similar organizations.

(Sec. 4) Directs the Administrative Office of the United States Courts, for each Federal court, to annually report to Congress on: (1) the number of times that a right under this Act is asserted in a criminal case and the relief requested is denied (and the reason for such denial); and (2) the number of times a mandamus action is brought pursuant to this Act and the result reached.

Requires the Comptroller General to study and report to Congress on the effect and efficacy of the implementation of this Act on the treatment of crime victims in the Federal system.

Congressional Research Service, via api.congress.gov (public domain)

Roll-call votes

1 on record

Apr 22, 2004 · On Passage of the Bill

Full roll call

Bill Passed (96–1)

62 of 100 recorded votes are not yet matched to a member profile.

Yea96: 20 D · 18 R

MemberPartyState
VOINOVICH, George VictorOH
LUGAR, Richard GreenIN
INOUYE, Daniel KenHI
SANTORUM, Richard JohnPA
LAUTENBERG, Frank RaleighNJ
STEVENS, Theodore FultonAK
DOMENICI, Pete VichiNM
BUNNING, James Paul DavidKY
CORZINE, Jon StevensNJ
BINGAMAN, Jesse Francis (Jeff), Jr.NM
BROWNBACK, Sam DaleKS
MILLER, Zell BryanGA
FEINGOLD, Russell DanaWI
LIEBERMAN, Joseph I.CT
BYRD, Robert CarlyleWV
ENSIGN, John EricNV
SARBANES, Paul SpyrosMD
DODD, Christopher JohnCT
HAGEL, Charles TimothyNE
DeWINE, MichaelOH
GREGG, Judd AlanNH
JEFFORDS, James MerrillVT
BREAUX, John BerlingerLA
BAUCUS, Max SiebenMT
DORGAN, Byron LeslieND
CRAIG, Larry EdwinID
THOMAS, Craig LyleWY
BOND, Christopher SamuelMO
FITZGERALD, Peter G.IL
SNOWE, Olympia JeanME
ALLARD, A. WayneCO
HUTCHISON, Kathryn Ann BaileyTX
COLEMAN, NormMN
CLINTON, Hillary RodhamNY
NELSON, Earl BenjaminNE
BAYH, EvanIN
SMITH, Gordon HaroldOR
DOLE, Elizabeth HanfordNC
BURNS, ConradMT
FRIST, William H.TN
KENNEDY, Edward MooreMA
LOTT, Chester TrentMS
KOHL, Herbert H.WI
LINCOLN, Blanche LambertAR
DASCHLE, Thomas AndrewSD
TALENT, James MatthesMO
GRAHAM, Daniel RobertFL
NICKLES, Donald LeeOK
BENNETT, Robert FosterUT
AKAKA, Daniel KahikinaHI
DAYTON, MarkMN
ALLEN, GeorgeVA
CHAFEE, Lincoln DavenportRI
WARNER, John WilliamVA
CONRAD, KentND
EDWARDS, JohnNC
SUNUNU, John E.NH
BIDEN, Joseph Robinette (Joe), Jr.DE
Mark L. PryorDemocratAR
Barbara BoxerDemocratCA
Dianne FeinsteinDemocratCA
Thomas R. CarperDemocratDE
Bill NelsonDemocratFL
Tom HarkinDemocratIA
Richard J. DurbinDemocratIL
Mary L. LandrieuDemocratLA
Barbara A. MikulskiDemocratMD
Carl LevinDemocratMI
Debbie StabenowDemocratMI
Harry ReidDemocratNV
Charles E. SchumerDemocratNY
Ron WydenDemocratOR
Jack ReedDemocratRI
Tim JohnsonDemocratSD
Patrick J. LeahyDemocratVT
Maria CantwellDemocratWA
Patty MurrayDemocratWA
John D. Rockefeller, IVDemocratWV
Lisa MurkowskiRepublicanAK
Jeff SessionsRepublicanAL
Richard C. ShelbyRepublicanAL
John McCainRepublicanAZ
Jon KylRepublicanAZ
Saxby ChamblissRepublicanGA
Chuck GrassleyRepublicanIA
Mike CrapoRepublicanID
Pat RobertsRepublicanKS
Mitch McConnellRepublicanKY
Susan M. CollinsRepublicanME
Thad CochranRepublicanMS
James M. InhofeRepublicanOK
Lindsey GrahamRepublicanSC
Lamar AlexanderRepublicanTN
John CornynRepublicanTX
Orrin G. HatchRepublicanUT
Michael B. EnziRepublicanWY

Nay1

MemberPartyState
HOLLINGS, Ernest FrederickSC

Not Voting3

MemberPartyState
SPECTER, ArlenPA
CAMPBELL, Ben NighthorseCO
KERRY, John ForbesMA

Member pages currently show roll-call votes from the 119th Congress only. The “Member pages” column marks votes from that congress.